kingswood Polak
Without music life would be a mistake
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 10,361
|
Post by kingswood Polak on Feb 7, 2021 12:35:15 GMT
Alternatives which as far as I can see would leave us no better off. I'm sorry you say that KP - I've no idea whether Wael is a nice guy or the devil incarnate, but it doesn't make much difference. At present he owns the club. I certainly don't view him as God. Ah - the polarisation of debate! He is neither the saviour, and neither is he the devil incarnate. I 100% think he is a nice guy. I've been lucky enough to meet him a couple of times, and his heart is in the right place. He really does care. He takes criticism very much to heart. But I think he needs a lot of help at the moment. I am concerned that the people he has around him are friends, rather than passionate Gasheads or hard-nosed businessmen with a strategy. As an aside, I think the criticisms of Tom Gorringe on here are largely unwarranted. Keep the Faith & UTG. Exactly right Ian, From what I found out, when I was still asking questions, he got quite a kick out of ridding the club of Steve Hamer and the others. He saw them as unnecessary and also as enemies. For the record SH was Hanis man. He then even puts out rumours that SH is giving disinformation , on the other place. He was very angry at SH and Ken but both were working on Hani’s behest. He then goes about surrounding himself with friends, who are yes men and there we have it. Like it or not, this is now a club that is run by one man.
|
|
axegas
Joined: November 2015
Posts: 222
|
Post by axegas on Feb 7, 2021 13:56:42 GMT
Oh my post is confusing? Firstly, I have no idea why you think that before Gorringe arrived losses were hovering around the £200k mark? To give you a picture of what they actually were for a few of the years prior to Gorringe’s appointment in late 2017. 2010: (1,079,843) 2011: (1,267,207) 2012: (704,020) 2013: (876,720) 2014: (648,845) 2015: (704,020) 2016: (751,001) 2017: (1,301,471) That covers all kinds of seasons, not just promotion/relegation ones. I think there is still lots of work to go of course, but credit to Gorringe for helping us post what I believe is our highest ever turnover of £6,461,681 in the latest accounts and I do think they were making a step in the right direction before the pandemic was hit as they were hoping to cut spending by £1.7 million according to Starnes. I believe Gorringe’s job as commercial director is to grow revenue rather than dictate spending, which he has done? Debt free. Yes we are. BRFC no longer owes BRFC 1883 LTD anything as the previous dept has been capitalised into shares. Regardless of whether you believe the merits of converting debt into equity are good ones, the fact remains that BRFC are debt free, they don’t have to pay any interest on the previous outstanding debt, that was paid off by Wael and there is no risk of the club going into liquidation if Wael was ever going to try to enforce repayment. What money is now owed, the shares satisfy the debt? It makes the club harder to sell down the line sure, but if Wael really wants to sell the club he could always convert equity back into debt and write it off himself. We weren’t in a better place before Wael arrived. We had a costly wonga loan taken out to fund a costly court case that we were never going to win. Debts were mounting, up to 8 million by June 2015. Why do you think Higgs sold up in 2016? We are now building a new training ground, have a well funded L1 squad, have better income streams such as Gorringe’s idea to keep to keep the 1883 sponsorship draw running but sell the main prize independently. There’s no chance, I’d want the club to go back to being run by Higgs. The figures quoted are for BRFC Ltd not the holding company BRFC 1883 Ltd and if we bring them up to date we will see : 2018: (2,611.685) 2019: (3,310.443) 2020: (4,000.000) estimate So in his quest for sustainability Wael has managed to at least triple and probably quadruple the average losses. I admire Tom Gorringe for raising the Rovers social media profile and engaging with younger fans but we just don’t know if he is successful commercially because no figures are available for his department. Overall the club turnover has increased but costs have risen by an even greater amount which is why losses are higher. There is a very good saying in business “ turnover is vanity, profit is sanity”. When we say “we” about Rovers I think we should speak about BRFC 1883 Ltd because that is where the figures are consolidated and that is the company which owns The Mem. At 30.06.19 BRFC 1883 Ltd owed 16 million to Dwane Sports and 4 million to other creditors. So when 18 million was capitalised in 2020 there was still 2 million debt. Add to this the probable 4 million lost in the 2020 financial year, at least another 2 million lost from July 2020 till now and a probable 2 million spent on the training ground and you have at least 10 million owed by BRFC 1883 Ltd to Dwane Sports. “We” are not debt free. I think you are mistaken if you believe we are going in the right direction. Wael’s quest for sustainability is a relatively recent thing and he’s only been sole owner of the club for a short amount of time. You quote 2020, but that hasn’t been published yet and of course when it does come, it will have the huge caveat that COVID 19 has made sustainability almost impossible to achieve at every football club up and down the country. We simply don’t have enough evidence to suggest if Wael has made the club more sustainable after saying he wants to do so, we shall see in the years to come. I used the term “we” to imitate the phrase that ThinWhiteDuke used in his post. Our argument was not whether Rovers were debt free at the moment, I accept we’re not if Wael has not chosen to do the same thing he did last summer, but whether what he did last summer amounted to us becoming substantially debt free at that moment in time or not. With the JCH money and the other cuts we were trying to make, I’m not sure we’ve lost as much as 4 million but again that’s just as speculative on my part as it is on yours. The accounts shall tell us when they are published. Also who is funding the training ground? I’m pretty sure it was Dwane Sports that purchased it in 2017, not BRFC1883 Ltd which suggests “we” aren’t the ones footing the bill, rather the parent company is. I think we are going in the right direction as a football club. I don’t believe any one on here to be “mistaken” in their views, just that some have different opinions to mine.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 7, 2021 14:57:41 GMT
Alternatives which as far as I can see would leave us no better off. I'm sorry you say that KP - I've no idea whether Wael is a nice guy or the devil incarnate, but it doesn't make much difference. At present he owns the club. I certainly don't view him as God. Ah - the polarisation of debate! He is neither the saviour, and neither is he the devil incarnate. I 100% think he is a nice guy. I've been lucky enough to meet him a couple of times, and his heart is in the right place. He really does care. He takes criticism very much to heart. But I think he needs a lot of help at the moment. I am concerned that the people he has around him are friends, rather than passionate Gasheads or hard-nosed businessmen with a strategy. As an aside, I think the criticisms of Tom Gorringe on here are largely unwarranted. Keep the Faith & UTG. As far as I'm aware he was responsible for the MintBet fiasco. In most situations that would have cost someone their job. Axegas. If you honestly think that Wael was involved with running the club for 4 years with no regard for sustainability and that doesn't worry you then I'm not surprised that we're struggling to agree on this topic, because it makes me look at his total exposure, look at our fag packet projected losses and worry very much what he's going to do when those totals combined exceed the value of all of the disposable assets.
|
|
|
Post by Topper Gas on Feb 7, 2021 14:59:17 GMT
Who are these mystery "friends" posters keep referring to? Starnes doesn't seem to have any real past connections with Wael and has been a reasonably successful CEO at Plymouth & Yeovil previously, Widdrington was brought in by DC and until the last window most posters thought he was doing a decent good, Gorringe seemed more a friend of Hamer's than Wael's and he seems to be a reasonable job and like MS seemed to do a good job at his previous club, only Kassim is a friend and I doubt his role his involved in the day to day running of the club. Perhaps 'friends' is the wrong word. I am pretty sure Wael knew MS prior to the appointment (I've know idea how well). It was certainly a very swift 'out of the blue' appointment. My concern is around the people he has at Board level and their ability to question Wael's decisions / business strategy, and hence their ability to move Rovers to the 'next level'. I'm looking for the passionate Gasheads and/or hard-nosed businessman in your response, and I can't find them. Did anybody question Geoff Dunford or Nick Higgs, or Steve Lansdown, running a football club is slightly different than running a PLC where you have to answer to shareholders etc, perhaps the Fans Director could be that "hard nosed" businessman/woman but the SC seems to have no interest in putting forward their chosen candidate. As far as MS I thought like JW with DC he just came across him by chance, I assume at around the time he was starting to fall out with Hamer.
|
|
|
Post by swissgas on Feb 7, 2021 16:14:15 GMT
The figures quoted are for BRFC Ltd not the holding company BRFC 1883 Ltd and if we bring them up to date we will see : 2018: (2,611.685) 2019: (3,310.443) 2020: (4,000.000) estimate So in his quest for sustainability Wael has managed to at least triple and probably quadruple the average losses. I admire Tom Gorringe for raising the Rovers social media profile and engaging with younger fans but we just don’t know if he is successful commercially because no figures are available for his department. Overall the club turnover has increased but costs have risen by an even greater amount which is why losses are higher. There is a very good saying in business “ turnover is vanity, profit is sanity”. When we say “we” about Rovers I think we should speak about BRFC 1883 Ltd because that is where the figures are consolidated and that is the company which owns The Mem. At 30.06.19 BRFC 1883 Ltd owed 16 million to Dwane Sports and 4 million to other creditors. So when 18 million was capitalised in 2020 there was still 2 million debt. Add to this the probable 4 million lost in the 2020 financial year, at least another 2 million lost from July 2020 till now and a probable 2 million spent on the training ground and you have at least 10 million owed by BRFC 1883 Ltd to Dwane Sports. “We” are not debt free. I think you are mistaken if you believe we are going in the right direction. Wael’s quest for sustainability is a relatively recent thing and he’s only been sole owner of the club for a short amount of time. You quote 2020, but that hasn’t been published yet and of course when it does come, it will have the huge caveat that COVID 19 has made sustainability almost impossible to achieve at every football club up and down the country. We simply don’t have enough evidence to suggest if Wael has made the club more sustainable after saying he wants to do so, we shall see in the years to come. I used the term “we” to imitate the phrase that ThinWhiteDuke used in his post. Our argument was not whether Rovers were debt free at the moment, I accept we’re not if Wael has not chosen to do the same thing he did last summer, but whether what he did last summer amounted to us becoming substantially debt free at that moment in time or not. With the JCH money and the other cuts we were trying to make, I’m not sure we’ve lost as much as 4 million but again that’s just as speculative on my part as it is on yours. The accounts shall tell us when they are published. Also who is funding the training ground? I’m pretty sure it was Dwane Sports that purchased it in 2017, not BRFC1883 Ltd which suggests “we” aren’t the ones footing the bill, rather the parent company is. I think we are going in the right direction as a football club. I don’t believe any one on here to be “mistaken” in their views, just that some have different opinions to mine. I agree that we all hold differing opinions while having the same goal and, contrary to Uncle Eppers mischief making, it isn’t a contest. But sometimes, because of our strong desire to see Rovers and Wael do well, we form entrenched opinions which are based upon emotion and which don’t stand up to scrutiny. In his August 2016 interview with Venture Magazine Wael was talking about Gasheads and said “ They don’t want anyone splashing the cash for short term success. They know it doesn’t work. It’s about building something sustainable”. I think it is beyond belief that anyone would take over a business and then wait 3 1/2 years before trying to make it sustainable. The COVID crisis only affected the final couple of months of the 2019/20 season so we will see the main impact of that in the 2021 accounts. Likewise JCH was sold in August 2020 so that income will also show in the 2021 accounts. The training ground is owned by Jersey based Dwane Colony Ltd and we have previously discussed the subject of who paid for its upkeep. The consensus is that Rovers paid for the upkeep, Rovers are paying for the new development and Rovers employees manage and maintain the facility. So Dwane Sports loan money to Rovers and Rovers use some of it at the training ground. Without wishing to go over this again my view is that if Dwane Colony Ltd had fully financed the training ground and it provided acceptable training facilities then there would be no reason to be opposed to Rovers paying a commercial rent for using it. But, for reasons which have never been explained, in the Spring of 2020 Rovers declined to lease a perfectly acceptable and competitively priced training facility but instead poured millions of precious cash into Almondsbury. And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team.
|
|
|
Post by Topper Gas on Feb 7, 2021 16:59:19 GMT
Wael’s quest for sustainability is a relatively recent thing and he’s only been sole owner of the club for a short amount of time. You quote 2020, but that hasn’t been published yet and of course when it does come, it will have the huge caveat that COVID 19 has made sustainability almost impossible to achieve at every football club up and down the country. We simply don’t have enough evidence to suggest if Wael has made the club more sustainable after saying he wants to do so, we shall see in the years to come. I used the term “we” to imitate the phrase that ThinWhiteDuke used in his post. Our argument was not whether Rovers were debt free at the moment, I accept we’re not if Wael has not chosen to do the same thing he did last summer, but whether what he did last summer amounted to us becoming substantially debt free at that moment in time or not. With the JCH money and the other cuts we were trying to make, I’m not sure we’ve lost as much as 4 million but again that’s just as speculative on my part as it is on yours. The accounts shall tell us when they are published. Also who is funding the training ground? I’m pretty sure it was Dwane Sports that purchased it in 2017, not BRFC1883 Ltd which suggests “we” aren’t the ones footing the bill, rather the parent company is. I think we are going in the right direction as a football club. I don’t believe any one on here to be “mistaken” in their views, just that some have different opinions to mine. I agree that we all hold differing opinions while having the same goal and, contrary to Uncle Eppers mischief making, it isn’t a contest. But sometimes, because of our strong desire to see Rovers and Wael do well, we form entrenched opinions which are based upon emotion and which don’t stand up to scrutiny. In his August 2016 interview with Venture Magazine Wael was talking about Gasheads and said “ They don’t want anyone splashing the cash for short term success. They know it doesn’t work. It’s about building something sustainable”. I think it is beyond belief that anyone would take over a business and then wait 3 1/2 years before trying to make it sustainable. The COVID crisis only affected the final couple of months of the 2019/20 season so we will see the main impact of that in the 2021 accounts. Likewise JCH was sold in August 2020 so that income will also show in the 2021 accounts. The training ground is owned by Jersey based Dwane Colony Ltd and we have previously discussed the subject of who paid for its upkeep. The consensus is that Rovers paid for the upkeep, Rovers are paying for the new development and Rovers employees manage and maintain the facility. So Dwane Sports loan money to Rovers and Rovers use some of it at the training ground. Without wishing to go over this again my view is that if Dwane Colony Ltd had fully financed the training ground and it provided acceptable training facilities then there would be no reason to be opposed to Rovers paying a commercial rent for using it. But, for reasons which have never been explained, in the Spring of 2020 Rovers declined to lease a perfectly acceptable and competitively priced training facility but instead poured millions of precious cash into Almondsbury. And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team. Where was it confirmed Rovers were paying for the training ground work, although if Wael owns DCJ Ltd and they own Rovers does it really matter who pays for it as it's Wael who has to finance the build at the end of the end. I can imagine he'd be similarly crisitied if he chooses to charge us a commercial rate, as Geoff Dunford was in the past. Wael must be the first club owner criticised for investing in it's own training facilities when it seems virtually every go ahead club, Luton, Lincoln, etc are doing similar. As far as not being able to recruit a decent football team, how do you think the rumoured deals to loan Stockley etc were going to be financed? The fact is PT has up to 27(?) L1 players, when they are all fit, at his disposal in January the fact they don't make a "decent" football team seems more down to poor recruitment/management than the lack of playing budget, I wouldn't be surprised if the playing budget isn't greater than Lincoln's who are top of the table.
|
|
eppinggas
Administrator
Ian Alexander
Don't care
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 8,604
|
Post by eppinggas on Feb 7, 2021 17:28:42 GMT
... I think we are going in the right direction as a football club. I don’t believe any one on here to be “mistaken” in their views, just that some have different opinions to mine. I agree that we all hold differing opinions while having the same goal and, contrary to Uncle Eppers mischief making, it isn’t a contest. But sometimes, because of our strong desire to see Rovers and Wael do well, we form entrenched opinions which are based upon emotion and which don’t stand up to scrutiny. In his August 2016 interview with Venture Magazine Wael was talking about Gasheads and said “ They don’t want anyone splashing the cash for short term success. They know it doesn’t work. It’s about building something sustainable”. I think it is beyond belief that anyone would take over a business and then wait 3 1/2 years before trying to make it sustainable. The COVID crisis only affected the final couple of months of the 2019/20 season so we will see the main impact of that in the 2021 accounts. Likewise JCH was sold in August 2020 so that income will also show in the 2021 accounts. The training ground is owned by Jersey based Dwane Colony Ltd and we have previously discussed the subject of who paid for its upkeep. The consensus is that Rovers paid for the upkeep, Rovers are paying for the new development and Rovers employees manage and maintain the facility. So Dwane Sports loan money to Rovers and Rovers use some of it at the training ground. Without wishing to go over this again my view is that if Dwane Colony Ltd had fully financed the training ground and it provided acceptable training facilities then there would be no reason to be opposed to Rovers paying a commercial rent for using it. But, for reasons which have never been explained, in the Spring of 2020 Rovers declined to lease a perfectly acceptable and competitively priced training facility but instead poured millions of precious cash into Almondsbury. And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team. Oh come on, it is a sort of contest. What fun. Two Gaschat stalwarts, axe & topper. Both been away from the crease for a while, apart from a few snippets from axe since Jan 24th. Both land on the same thread at the same time when some kind of defence for the Board is required. "Coming in to bat at a difficult time" springs to mind. Both looking a bit like tail-enders facing a pumped up swissgas with the new ball. They've only got irenestoyboy to come in at no 10 and it's game over. No offence intended Topper Gas and axegas , your views are always welcome. Bants. We all want is what's best for Bristol Rovers FC. UTG.
|
|
|
Post by laughinggas on Feb 7, 2021 17:29:53 GMT
poured millions of precious cash into Almondsbury. And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team.
Making accusations like that make me lose confidence in the rest of your post.
Really you expect is to go and spend a million on a striker?
Plus over the top wages and the impact that might have on the squad!
|
|
|
Post by Topper Gas on Feb 7, 2021 17:46:08 GMT
I agree that we all hold differing opinions while having the same goal and, contrary to Uncle Eppers mischief making, it isn’t a contest. But sometimes, because of our strong desire to see Rovers and Wael do well, we form entrenched opinions which are based upon emotion and which don’t stand up to scrutiny. In his August 2016 interview with Venture Magazine Wael was talking about Gasheads and said “ They don’t want anyone splashing the cash for short term success. They know it doesn’t work. It’s about building something sustainable”. I think it is beyond belief that anyone would take over a business and then wait 3 1/2 years before trying to make it sustainable. The COVID crisis only affected the final couple of months of the 2019/20 season so we will see the main impact of that in the 2021 accounts. Likewise JCH was sold in August 2020 so that income will also show in the 2021 accounts. The training ground is owned by Jersey based Dwane Colony Ltd and we have previously discussed the subject of who paid for its upkeep. The consensus is that Rovers paid for the upkeep, Rovers are paying for the new development and Rovers employees manage and maintain the facility. So Dwane Sports loan money to Rovers and Rovers use some of it at the training ground. Without wishing to go over this again my view is that if Dwane Colony Ltd had fully financed the training ground and it provided acceptable training facilities then there would be no reason to be opposed to Rovers paying a commercial rent for using it. But, for reasons which have never been explained, in the Spring of 2020 Rovers declined to lease a perfectly acceptable and competitively priced training facility but instead poured millions of precious cash into Almondsbury. And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team. Oh come on, it is a sort of contest. What fun. Two Gaschat stalwarts, axe & topper. Both been away from the crease for a while, apart from a few snippets from axe since Jan 24th. Both land on the same thread at the same time when some kind of defence for the Board is required. "Coming in to bat at a difficult time" springs to mind. Both looking a bit like tail-enders facing a pumped up swissgas with the new ball. They've only got irenestoyboy to come in at no 10 and it's game over. No offence intended Topper Gas and axegas , your views are always welcome. Bants. We all want is what's best for Bristol Rovers FC. UTG. No offence but I'm not a Wael fan boy, I couldn't care less who owns the club as long as it's stable/one day we make some progress, I only looked at this forum after Dave Townsend started posting on Gaschat and felt it was appropriate to answer some of the nonsense SwissGas is posting after I read the thread, if you are happy to read it unchallenged then I'll go back to posting on Gaschat, although I see other posters are now responding to the nonsense he's posting.
|
|
Cheshiregas
Global Moderator
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 2,979
|
Post by Cheshiregas on Feb 7, 2021 18:29:25 GMT
I agree that we all hold differing opinions while having the same goal and, contrary to Uncle Eppers mischief making, it isn’t a contest. But sometimes, because of our strong desire to see Rovers and Wael do well, we form entrenched opinions which are based upon emotion and which don’t stand up to scrutiny.... And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team.Bearing in mind your first comment, is the last comment fact Swiss or speculation? I understood we were near our max on players within Financial rules and couldn't bring someone else in unless we offloaded which we didn't. Stand to be corrected naturally, thanks.
|
|
|
Post by swissgas on Feb 7, 2021 18:33:06 GMT
I agree that we all hold differing opinions while having the same goal and, contrary to Uncle Eppers mischief making, it isn’t a contest. But sometimes, because of our strong desire to see Rovers and Wael do well, we form entrenched opinions which are based upon emotion and which don’t stand up to scrutiny. In his August 2016 interview with Venture Magazine Wael was talking about Gasheads and said “ They don’t want anyone splashing the cash for short term success. They know it doesn’t work. It’s about building something sustainable”. I think it is beyond belief that anyone would take over a business and then wait 3 1/2 years before trying to make it sustainable. The COVID crisis only affected the final couple of months of the 2019/20 season so we will see the main impact of that in the 2021 accounts. Likewise JCH was sold in August 2020 so that income will also show in the 2021 accounts. The training ground is owned by Jersey based Dwane Colony Ltd and we have previously discussed the subject of who paid for its upkeep. The consensus is that Rovers paid for the upkeep, Rovers are paying for the new development and Rovers employees manage and maintain the facility. So Dwane Sports loan money to Rovers and Rovers use some of it at the training ground. Without wishing to go over this again my view is that if Dwane Colony Ltd had fully financed the training ground and it provided acceptable training facilities then there would be no reason to be opposed to Rovers paying a commercial rent for using it. But, for reasons which have never been explained, in the Spring of 2020 Rovers declined to lease a perfectly acceptable and competitively priced training facility but instead poured millions of precious cash into Almondsbury. And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team. Where was it confirmed Rovers were paying for the training ground work, although if Wael owns DCJ Ltd and they own Rovers does it really matter who pays for it as it's Wael who has to finance the build at the end of the end. I can imagine he'd be similarly crisitied if he chooses to charge us a commercial rate, as Geoff Dunford was in the past. Wael must be the first club owner criticised for investing in it's own training facilities when it seems virtually every go ahead club, Luton, Lincoln, etc are doing similar. As far as not being able to recruit a decent football team, how do you think the rumoured deals to loan Stockley etc were going to be financed? The fact is PT has up to 27(?) L1 players, when they are all fit, at his disposal in January the fact they don't make a "decent" football team seems more down to poor recruitment/management than the lack of playing budget, I wouldn't be surprised if the playing budget isn't greater than Lincoln's who are top of the table. For older fans, here’s Fred Rumsey coming on to bowl from the Oil Drum Lane end. We know so little about the training ground, no full plans, no artists impressions, no webcams, no publicity or updates from the club that surely any reasonable person would wonder why it is so shrouded in mystery ? What publicity there has been has indicated that Rovers are taking responsibility for the bills and it has been suggested one reason for this is because the club is registered for VAT whereas Dwane Colony Ltd are not. Whatever the case I hope there is a formal agreement between the two companies so no misunderstanding can arise in future. I said at the outset that it was a bad decision to embark on a large capital project when good alternatives were available and that some of the cash should have been set aside to give us the flexibility to make changes should the football team and manager turn out to be unsuccessful. If you think money was no barrier to making those changes and that we have the best manager, coaches and players available then that is up to you. Lincoln and Luton are both successful football clubs who have evidently used their resources wisely. Lincoln are top of the league and have spent 1.3 million on a training ground using money from their FA cup run from a few years ago. Luton are planning a full size indoor dome to complement their existing training ground with the aim of consolidating the Championship status they achieved through competent management.
|
|
|
Post by swissgas on Feb 7, 2021 18:59:46 GMT
I agree that we all hold differing opinions while having the same goal and, contrary to Uncle Eppers mischief making, it isn’t a contest. But sometimes, because of our strong desire to see Rovers and Wael do well, we form entrenched opinions which are based upon emotion and which don’t stand up to scrutiny.... And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team.Bearing in mind your first comment, is the last comment fact Swiss or speculation? I understood we were near our max on players within Financial rules and couldn't bring someone else in unless we offloaded which we didn't. Stand to be corrected naturally, thanks. Just an opinion based on what I read and hear Cheshire. Paul Tisdale said he wanted to make signings, it was fairly clear we needed a striker, we were told no one suitable was available, other competing clubs managed to sign strikers so the conclusion can only be that either we have very specific requirements or we could not reach an agreement with the desired player or their club. And if we could not reach an agreement I think the chances are it was to do with money. I’m sure offloading players to free up squad places would not be an issue if we agreed to cover the wage costs, again a money issue. The same thing applies with coaching staff. It appears we need at least a specialist defensive coach and yet Jack Mesure is still here and being paid. Likely to be about money IMO.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 7, 2021 19:06:19 GMT
I agree that we all hold differing opinions while having the same goal and, contrary to Uncle Eppers mischief making, it isn’t a contest. But sometimes, because of our strong desire to see Rovers and Wael do well, we form entrenched opinions which are based upon emotion and which don’t stand up to scrutiny. In his August 2016 interview with Venture Magazine Wael was talking about Gasheads and said “ They don’t want anyone splashing the cash for short term success. They know it doesn’t work. It’s about building something sustainable”. I think it is beyond belief that anyone would take over a business and then wait 3 1/2 years before trying to make it sustainable. The COVID crisis only affected the final couple of months of the 2019/20 season so we will see the main impact of that in the 2021 accounts. Likewise JCH was sold in August 2020 so that income will also show in the 2021 accounts. The training ground is owned by Jersey based Dwane Colony Ltd and we have previously discussed the subject of who paid for its upkeep. The consensus is that Rovers paid for the upkeep, Rovers are paying for the new development and Rovers employees manage and maintain the facility. So Dwane Sports loan money to Rovers and Rovers use some of it at the training ground. Without wishing to go over this again my view is that if Dwane Colony Ltd had fully financed the training ground and it provided acceptable training facilities then there would be no reason to be opposed to Rovers paying a commercial rent for using it. But, for reasons which have never been explained, in the Spring of 2020 Rovers declined to lease a perfectly acceptable and competitively priced training facility but instead poured millions of precious cash into Almondsbury. And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team. Where was it confirmed Rovers were paying for the training ground work, although if Wael owns DCJ Ltd and they own Rovers does it really matter who pays for it as it's Wael who has to finance the build at the end of the end. I can imagine he'd be similarly crisitied if he chooses to charge us a commercial rate, as Geoff Dunford was in the past. Wael must be the first club owner criticised for investing in it's own training facilities when it seems virtually every go ahead club, Luton, Lincoln, etc are doing similar. As far as not being able to recruit a decent football team, how do you think the rumoured deals to loan Stockley etc were going to be financed? The fact is PT has up to 27(?) L1 players, when they are all fit, at his disposal in January the fact they don't make a "decent" football team seems more down to poor recruitment/management than the lack of playing budget, I wouldn't be surprised if the playing budget isn't greater than Lincoln's who are top of the table. Go back a few years and the initial works were billed to the offshore Dwane company but there was a problem as VAT could not be recovered as they were offshore so all future costs were invoiced to BRFC who they were able to reclaim VAT on the works carried out.
|
|
|
Post by gasheadnaboo on Feb 7, 2021 19:51:13 GMT
Bearing in mind your first comment, is the last comment fact Swiss or speculation? I understood we were near our max on players within Financial rules and couldn't bring someone else in unless we offloaded which we didn't. Stand to be corrected naturally, thanks. Just an opinion based on what I read and hear Cheshire. Paul Tisdale said he wanted to make signings, it was fairly clear we needed a striker, we were told no one suitable was available, other competing clubs managed to sign strikers so the conclusion can only be that either we have very specific requirements or we could not reach an agreement with the desired player or their club. And if we could not reach an agreement I think the chances are it was to do with money. I’m sure offloading players to free up squad places would not be an issue if we agreed to cover the wage costs, again a money issue. The same thing applies with coaching staff. It appears we need at least a specialist defensive coach and yet Jack Mesure is still here and being paid. Likely to be about money IMO. Jack Mesure is probably Wael's boy, considering he came in from his much fêted Chelsea. Would also explain why Grant seems to be undroppable also.
|
|
womble
Arthur Cartlidge
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 300
|
Post by womble on Feb 7, 2021 19:55:57 GMT
Wael’s quest for sustainability is a relatively recent thing and he’s only been sole owner of the club for a short amount of time. You quote 2020, but that hasn’t been published yet and of course when it does come, it will have the huge caveat that COVID 19 has made sustainability almost impossible to achieve at every football club up and down the country. We simply don’t have enough evidence to suggest if Wael has made the club more sustainable after saying he wants to do so, we shall see in the years to come. I used the term “we” to imitate the phrase that ThinWhiteDuke used in his post. Our argument was not whether Rovers were debt free at the moment, I accept we’re not if Wael has not chosen to do the same thing he did last summer, but whether what he did last summer amounted to us becoming substantially debt free at that moment in time or not. With the JCH money and the other cuts we were trying to make, I’m not sure we’ve lost as much as 4 million but again that’s just as speculative on my part as it is on yours. The accounts shall tell us when they are published. Also who is funding the training ground? I’m pretty sure it was Dwane Sports that purchased it in 2017, not BRFC1883 Ltd which suggests “we” aren’t the ones footing the bill, rather the parent company is. I think we are going in the right direction as a football club. I don’t believe any one on here to be “mistaken” in their views, just that some have different opinions to mine. But, for reasons which have never been explained, in the Spring of 2020 Rovers declined to lease a perfectly acceptable and competitively priced training facility but instead poured millions of precious cash into Almondsbury. And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team.Which training facility are you referring to Swiss?
|
|
|
Post by Topper Gas on Feb 7, 2021 21:06:07 GMT
But, for reasons which have never been explained, in the Spring of 2020 Rovers declined to lease a perfectly acceptable and competitively priced training facility but instead poured millions of precious cash into Almondsbury. And now we have discovered that there is not enough left to recruit a decent football team. Which training facility are you referring to Swiss? It's odd somebody based in a different country knows all about the club being offered alternative training facilities but nobody living in Bristol appears to have heard anything about them. Similarly with the playing budget on the one hand, the raises concerns we're still running up large debts, on the other wants us to have a squad bigger than the present 27(?) players even though we can only name 22 players in the squad and I'm not aware of many other L1 clubs paying their players just to sit in the stands.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 7, 2021 21:35:27 GMT
Which training facility are you referring to Swiss? It's odd somebody based in a different country knows all about the club being offered alternative training facilities but nobody living in Bristol appears to have heard anything about them. Similarly with the playing budget on the one hand, the raises concerns we're still running up large debts, on the other wants us to have a squad bigger than the present 27(?) players even though we can only name 22 players in the squad and I'm not aware of many other L1 clubs paying their players just to sit in the stands. I'm sure Wael is kept fully up to date despite living in Jordan. As for Swissgas, his channels of communication are state of the art.
|
|
bloogas
Joined: July 2016
Posts: 1,119
|
Post by bloogas on Feb 7, 2021 22:34:51 GMT
Which training facility are you referring to Swiss? It's odd somebody based in a different country knows all about the club being offered alternative training facilities but nobody living in Bristol appears to have heard anything about them. Similarly with the playing budget on the one hand, the raises concerns we're still running up large debts, on the other wants us to have a squad bigger than the present 27(?) players even though we can only name 22 players in the squad and I'm not aware of many other L1 clubs paying their players just to sit in the stands. Yes, several discrepancies and contradictions.
|
|
eppinggas
Administrator
Ian Alexander
Don't care
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 8,604
|
Post by eppinggas on Feb 7, 2021 22:57:05 GMT
Which training facility are you referring to Swiss? It's odd somebody based in a different country knows all about the club being offered alternative training facilities but nobody living in Bristol appears to have heard anything about them. Similarly with the playing budget on the one hand, the raises concerns we're still running up large debts, on the other wants us to have a squad bigger than the present 27(?) players even though we can only name 22 players in the squad and I'm not aware of many other L1 clubs paying their players just to sit in the stands. Sorry - I must have missed that. Where was that stated?
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 7, 2021 23:45:48 GMT
I agree that we all hold differing opinions while having the same goal and, contrary to Uncle Eppers mischief making, it isn’t a contest. Isn't it? As long as we're all calling the new Guzzler administrator 'Uncle Eppers' now, I'm a very happy duck.
|
|