harrybuckle
Always look on the bright side
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 5,571
|
Post by harrybuckle on Oct 26, 2023 20:15:34 GMT
I am not a fan of Barton as a man, but as a football manager (only) he has my respect. He turned the club around on the football pitch, and we were starting to build a decent football team in League One (again). He is a decent manager who will have no trouble finding another club. I find this a strange time to let him go. He has a long contract and whilst we have not set League One on fire (yet), we are not even halfway through the season. Given that we always start slowly I still had expectations for this season. As many have said, a devisive character who regularly embarasses the club, so hopefully we can move forward as a unified fanbase again. Absolutely critical we get the right person in, there is still potentially a promotion to be had this season (or next). UTG I agree. I can’t imagine getting in relegation trouble under Barton, he has brought good quality here, it will be a good spell at some point this season. What was refreshing under Barton, the success he had with very old players. Under the previous master plan it was all about young players, and that plan brought in a lot of flawed players who would never make it. Barton’s Dad’s Army didn’t just bring the first touch from higher divisions, they brought a mental strength to the side. And the promotion was built upon that. for me, we need to get on the phone to Man City. For Gareth Taylor. Still not forgiven Tsylor for missing that golden chance at Wembley stadium in play offs.
|
|
|
Post by emperorsuperbus on Oct 26, 2023 20:20:45 GMT
yes, the moment new owners came in, today was always on the cards. New owners like to change things. but. We are not a championship ground. Not a championship club. Not a championship side. What do the owners actually want from this season and next? ROI Simples But you’ve still not answered the question, what is Return on Investment at this club right now, for the years ahead? Spending the next 8 seasons in this division without getting relegated, a credible ROI?
|
|
|
Post by emperorsuperbus on Oct 26, 2023 20:26:57 GMT
I agree. I can’t imagine getting in relegation trouble under Barton, he has brought good quality here, it will be a good spell at some point this season. What was refreshing under Barton, the success he had with very old players. Under the previous master plan it was all about young players, and that plan brought in a lot of flawed players who would never make it. Barton’s Dad’s Army didn’t just bring the first touch from higher divisions, they brought a mental strength to the side. And the promotion was built upon that. for me, we need to get on the phone to Man City. For Gareth Taylor. Still not forgiven Tsylor for missing that golden chance at Wembley stadium in play offs. You don’t forgive and forget very easily do you? The amazing seasons he had, after being converted from a centreback, actually got us to Wembley in the first place; and not that many points from a title. More importantly he has been schooled up there as a coach. And where does he want to take the rest of his managerial career? He would surely be tempted. He would be hungry. And he would be very interesting project for a board to Invest their money in.
|
|
Cheshiregas
Global Moderator
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 2,979
|
Post by Cheshiregas on Oct 26, 2023 20:47:13 GMT
I am not a fan of Barton as a man, but as a football manager (only) he has my respect. He turned the club around on the football pitch, and we were starting to build a decent football team in League One (again). He is a decent manager who will have no trouble finding another club. I find this a strange time to let him go. He has a long contract and whilst we have not set League One on fire (yet), we are not even halfway through the season. Given that we always start slowly I still had expectations for this season. As many have said, a devisive character who regularly embarasses the club, so hopefully we can move forward as a unified fanbase again.Absolutely critical we get the right person in, there is still potentially a promotion to be had this season (or next). UTG I wouldn't bet on that Rich A lot of Facebook fans slagging off the 'Barton haters' and saying none of them go to matches anyway and not true fans, etc. etc A lot of the Barton supporters are very angry with everyone, from the owners to his critics. Don't expect too much unity just yet!
|
|
bluetornados
Predictions League
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 15,755
|
Post by bluetornados on Oct 26, 2023 21:01:24 GMT
Still not forgiven Tsylor for missing that golden chance at Wembley stadium in play offs. You don’t forgive and forget very easily do you? The amazing seasons he had, after being converted from a centreback, actually got us to Wembley in the first place; and not that many points from a title. More importantly he has been schooled up there as a coach. And where does he want to take the rest of his managerial career? He would surely be tempted. He would be hungry. And he would be very interesting project for a board to Invest their money in. W-S-M born Gareth Taylor is 50 years old and played for BRFC 57 times, scoring 16 goals, he played for 13 teams and played 15 games for Wales scoring 1 goal...
|
|
|
Post by rideintothesun on Oct 26, 2023 21:06:47 GMT
Still not forgiven Tsylor for missing that golden chance at Wembley stadium in play offs. You don’t forgive and forget very easily do you? The amazing seasons he had, after being converted from a centreback, actually got us to Wembley in the first place; and not that many points from a title. More importantly he has been schooled up there as a coach. And where does he want to take the rest of his managerial career? He would surely be tempted. He would be hungry. And he would be very interesting project for a board to Invest their money in. Its interesting - in that season, all of the goals that he scored were headers. When Palace moved in for him, some of our fans thought they got him mixed up with Stewart, who was far more of an accomplished player. However, Taylor went on to become a solid championship striker, enjoying substantial success at both Sheff Utd and Burnley. I think people are suggesting Taylor to virtue-signal and pretend they aren't fully aware there is a huge gulf between the men's and women's game. Bear in mind our recent history of appointing managers is extremely poor. Coughlan was the cheap option; Garner was an unproven coach; Tisdale wasn't suited to firefighting; Barton was bright and flashy, but ultimately flattered to deceive.
|
|
|
Post by chelt_gas on Oct 26, 2023 21:12:36 GMT
I think the new owners will want someone with a more professional, refined approach. The issues associated with Barton overtook some jog his positive traits - confidence, recruitment, certain benchmarking.
Our new manager will be based on what the club will offer - if we have a budget and a believable plan then I think we’ll be happy with the new appointment.
|
|
bluetornados
Predictions League
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 15,755
|
Post by bluetornados on Oct 26, 2023 21:22:49 GMT
When a manager is sacked the club usually has a target in mind, will be very interesting to see who the new incumbent will be...
Recent sacked managers who are available include:
Mark Kennedy Xisco Munez Mark Hughes Neil Harris John Eustace Micky Mellon Graham Alexander Gary Rowett Michael Beale
Or An Other
|
|
lostinspace
Vic Lambden
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 5,727
Member is Online
|
Post by lostinspace on Oct 26, 2023 21:24:10 GMT
I am not a fan of Barton as a man, but as a football manager (only) he has my respect. He turned the club around on the football pitch, and we were starting to build a decent football team in League One (again). He is a decent manager who will have no trouble finding another club. I find this a strange time to let him go. He has a long contract and whilst we have not set League One on fire (yet), we are not even halfway through the season. Given that we always start slowly I still had expectations for this season. As many have said, a devisive character who regularly embarasses the club, so hopefully we can move forward as a unified fanbase again.Absolutely critical we get the right person in, there is still potentially a promotion to be had this season (or next). UTG I wouldn't bet on that Rich A lot of Facebook fans slagging off the 'Barton haters' and saying none of them go to matches anyway and not true fans, etc. etc A lot of the Barton supporters are very angry with everyone, from the owners to his critics. Don't expect too much unity just yet! the "love him " fans can rant and rave against "the haters?" ,accuse who they need to at his dismissal to make themselves feel vindicated in their anger.......BUT at the end of the day it's those who dish out the money that match and dispatch ......and as DC would say...."we move on"
|
|
|
Post by rideintothesun on Oct 26, 2023 21:27:51 GMT
When a manager is sacked the club usually has a target in mind, will be very interesting to see who the new incumbent will be... Recent sacked managers who are available include:Mark Kennedy Xisco Munez Mark Hughes Neil Harris John Eustace Micky Mellon Graham Alexander Gary Rowett Michael Beale Or An Other Depressing. Holloway anybody?
|
|
|
Post by emperorsuperbus on Oct 26, 2023 23:24:25 GMT
You don’t forgive and forget very easily do you? The amazing seasons he had, after being converted from a centreback, actually got us to Wembley in the first place; and not that many points from a title. More importantly he has been schooled up there as a coach. And where does he want to take the rest of his managerial career? He would surely be tempted. He would be hungry. And he would be very interesting project for a board to Invest their money in. Its interesting - in that season, all of the goals that he scored were headers. When Palace moved in for him, some of our fans thought they got him mixed up with Stewart, who was far more of an accomplished player. However, Taylor went on to become a solid championship striker, enjoying substantial success at both Sheff Utd and Burnley. I think people are suggesting Taylor to virtue-signal and pretend they aren't fully aware there is a huge gulf between the men's and women's game. Bear in mind our recent history of appointing managers is extremely poor. Coughlan was the cheap option; Garner was an unproven coach; Tisdale wasn't suited to firefighting; Barton was bright and flashy, but ultimately flattered to deceive. I remember watching Gas at Main Rd, and Taylor playing for Man City. That was tier 3. I’m virtue signalling? But I have no virtue left to signal. What a great set up they have at Man City these days, and are we underestimating the quality of player and coaching at the very top echelons of the ladies game? I don’t want to come over all Kevin Keegan, but do they play on same size pitch and goal frames as the men? The goalies all seem small in it, surely you only have to lob it for a great chance of a score? Coughlan was the cheap option - he was great for us! I’d have him back. Garner was an unproven coach. That might be harsh, he did do lot of coaching at number 2 at top levels. What he did sign up to, to seal his first manager job (the one Cocko walked from) was not to be in control. There was a master plan, and he didn’t really have control of transfers. Joey Barton was right, we were relegated that season because the players were rubbish and team lacked back bone. Things didn’t improve till Barton wrestled the control back to the managers desk and inverted that master plan with injection of experience and quality, and leaders on the field. Tisdale wasn't suited to firefighting. Tisdale was just weird. Exeter fans used to say they had great players but he picked weird teams. He did that here too. Plus that same master plan was still in control. Tisdale found Cocko’s old coffee in the cupboard and smelt it. Barton was bright and flashy, but ultimately flattered to deceive. Barton has done well for Bristol Rovers. We bounced straight back due to the team he built and managed whilst wrestling control at the club. After previous relegations we have floundered in the basement. If the club didn’t have new owners Barton would not be sacked this week. Unless of course he said something behind the scenes he shouldn’t have. There is a hugely divisive war going on. There is no way Barton should be sacked this week for football reasons. The board could not have said to him they expect promotion this season and we’ll sack you if you drift too far from expectations - that would be ludicrous, off pitch this club is nowhere near ready to sustain championship football, nor on it, where not a single pundit fancies us for top six. what is sad about Joey Barton, and yes we can call this right now, no matter his qualities as a player and as a manager, he will always have Joey Barton there with him wherever he goes, outspoken in a bizarre era where you can’t even fatshame Steve Cheating ******** Evans, the Barton history of trouble, excuses, 2nd chances, but also a tad insecure and immature. People like that can never change. Wherever Barton the manager goes, he will never escape the shadow of Joey the controversial celebrity.
|
|
|
Post by Mrs V Smegma on Oct 27, 2023 0:30:04 GMT
When a manager is sacked the club usually has a target in mind, will be very interesting to see who the new incumbent will be... Recent sacked managers who are available include:Mark Kennedy Xisco Munez Mark Hughes Neil Harris John Eustace Micky Mellon Graham Alexander Gary Rowett Michael Beale Or An Other Depressing. Holloway anybody? No thanks. Going back seldom takes you forward
|
|
|
Post by sethstarkadder on Oct 27, 2023 0:37:02 GMT
Good.
Awful gobsh1te who’s not even a decent manager: he’s leaving the club in roughly the place it was in when he swaggered in.
He promised the Earth, without a cheque guarantee card, and only delivered a claw back from a downturn that he served up. All accompanied by noise, bluster, offensiveness, repeated rebuilds, slagging-offs, rinse-and-repeat, and here we go again.
I coped with defending my allegiance against decades of under-performance, but have been embarrassed to be associated with the club led by him.
Good riddance. Shame it took as long as it did (and that they fell for and made excuses for it in the first place).
[Hello, btw]
|
|
|
Post by Mrs V Smegma on Oct 27, 2023 0:45:47 GMT
Its interesting - in that season, all of the goals that he scored were headers. When Palace moved in for him, some of our fans thought they got him mixed up with Stewart, who was far more of an accomplished player. However, Taylor went on to become a solid championship striker, enjoying substantial success at both Sheff Utd and Burnley. I think people are suggesting Taylor to virtue-signal and pretend they aren't fully aware there is a huge gulf between the men's and women's game. Bear in mind our recent history of appointing managers is extremely poor. Coughlan was the cheap option; Garner was an unproven coach; Tisdale wasn't suited to firefighting; Barton was bright and flashy, but ultimately flattered to deceive. I remember watching Gas at Main Rd, and Taylor playing for Man City. That was tier 3. I’m virtue signalling? But I have no virtue left to signal. What a great set up they have at Man City these days, and are we underestimating the quality of player and coaching at the very top echelons of the ladies game? I don’t want to come over all Kevin Keegan, but do they play on same size pitch and goal frames as the men? The goalies all seem small in it, surely you only have to lob it for a great chance of a score? Coughlan was the cheap option - he was great for us! I’d have him back. Garner was an unproven coach. That might be harsh, he did do lot of coaching at number 2 at top levels. What he did sign up to, to seal his first manager job (the one Cocko walked from) was not to be in control. There was a master plan, and he didn’t really have control of transfers. Joey Barton was right, we were relegated that season because the players were rubbish and team lacked back bone. Things didn’t improve till Barton wrestled the control back to the managers desk and inverted that master plan with injection of experience and quality, and leaders on the field. Tisdale wasn't suited to firefighting. Tisdale was just weird. Exeter fans used to say they had great players but he picked weird teams. He did that here too. Plus that same master plan was still in control. Tisdale found Cocko’s old coffee in the cupboard and smelt it. Barton was bright and flashy, but ultimately flattered to deceive. Barton has done well for Bristol Rovers. We bounced straight back due to the team he built and managed whilst wrestling control at the club. After previous relegations we have floundered in the basement. If the club didn’t have new owners Barton would not be sacked this week. Unless of course he said something behind the scenes he shouldn’t have. There is a hugely divisive war going on. There is no way Barton should be sacked this week for football reasons. The board could not have said to him they expect promotion this season and we’ll sack you if you drift too far from expectations - that would be ludicrous, off pitch this club is nowhere near ready to sustain championship football, nor on it, where not a single pundit fancies us for top six. what is sad about Joey Barton, and yes we can call this right now, no matter his qualities as a player and as a manager, he will always have Joey Barton there with him wherever he goes, outspoken in a bizarre era where you can’t even fatshame Steve Cheating ******** Evans, the Barton history of trouble, excuses, 2nd chances, but also a tad insecure and immature. People like that can never change. Wherever Barton the manager goes, he will never escape the shadow of Joey the controversial celebrity. Definitely deserved to be sacked for footballing reasons imho. If Swiss is right (and I’ve no reason to doubt him) we are spending an awful lot of money to go backwards. 17th last season was just about acceptable as first season at a higher level but we underperformed because Barton can’t get the best out of his squad and is a mediocre manager. We are no better this season and he has had even more money invested in the squad. He has created a very lop sided squad too. We did need some more experience but he has gone for it in the wrong places. A Coutts/Whelan replacement would make us much harder to beat He has proven with us and Fleetwood that he is not very good at all. Anyone else offering him a managers job needs their head read.
|
|
harrybuckle
Always look on the bright side
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 5,571
|
Post by harrybuckle on Oct 27, 2023 4:37:21 GMT
5 wins out of the last 24 league games frankly isn't good enough, by anyone's standards. If Wigan Athletic didn't have a points deduction, we would be 2 points off the relegation zone. When Barton took us over, we were in a similar position in league one and he said how bad we were.
Yes, he took us up.but also got us relegated. He admitted himself he got lucky with the Elliot Anderson signing and we only went up then, because we played a poor inexperienced team in Scunthorpe on the final day. It's true he has been backed in the transfer market obtaining expensive premier league youngsters and has had better facilities than any previous manager with a quitw superb training ground. Upsetting match refs. Calling out our own players Clarke Thomas twice Belshaw and McCormick was unacceptable as was him receiving a 3 match stadium ban after an incident with a referee. Winding up opponents managers the Cowley brothers the Plymouth and Exeter coaches and Wycombe manager and most recently the Stevenage manager has caused unnecessary controversy. Also don't forget the bad publicity following his high profile court cases with former Barnsley manager and his own wife. Add it all up and the fact over 35 players have come and gone in and we are now exactky the same position in league one as we were when he replaced Paul Tisdale. The league table does not lie.
|
|
bluetornados
Predictions League
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 15,755
|
Post by bluetornados on Oct 27, 2023 8:10:45 GMT
|
|
eppinggas
Administrator
Ian Alexander
Don't care
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 8,604
|
Post by eppinggas on Oct 27, 2023 8:23:35 GMT
I am not a fan of Barton as a man, but as a football manager (only) he has my respect. He turned the club around on the football pitch, and we were starting to build a decent football team in League One (again). He is a decent manager who will have no trouble finding another club. I find this a strange time to let him go. He has a long contract and whilst we have not set League One on fire (yet), we are not even halfway through the season. Given that we always start slowly I still had expectations for this season. As many have said, a devisive character who regularly embarasses the club, so hopefully we can move forward as a unified fanbase again. Absolutely critical we get the right person in, there is still potentially a promotion to be had this season (or next). UTG A balanced post and I respect your views. But (you knew there was going to be a but) - this is the third year which has seen a total 'rebuild'. Which consists of old players, injury prone players and loanees. Even if Barton manages a year of relative success based on luck & chemistry, a total rebuild would be required the next year. As yet, we don't know the real reason the Club have sacked him. I have a feeling Barton will sling mud and trash talk his way out of the door, tarnishing his reputation further. I sincerely doubt another EFL Club would gamble on him.
|
|
kingswood Polak
Without music life would be a mistake
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 10,361
|
Post by kingswood Polak on Oct 27, 2023 9:05:07 GMT
I am not a fan of Barton as a man, but as a football manager (only) he has my respect. He turned the club around on the football pitch, and we were starting to build a decent football team in League One (again). He is a decent manager who will have no trouble finding another club. I find this a strange time to let him go. He has a long contract and whilst we have not set League One on fire (yet), we are not even halfway through the season. Given that we always start slowly I still had expectations for this season. As many have said, a devisive character who regularly embarasses the club, so hopefully we can move forward as a unified fanbase again. Absolutely critical we get the right person in, there is still potentially a promotion to be had this season (or next). UTG A balanced post and I respect your views. But (you knew there was going to be a but) - this is the third year which has seen a total 'rebuild'. Which consists of old players, injury prone players and loanees. Even if Barton manages a year of relative success based on luck & chemistry, a total rebuild would be required the next year. As yet, we don't know the real reason the Club have sacked him. I have a feeling Barton will sling mud and trash talk his way out of the door, tarnishing his reputation further. I sincerely doubt another EFL Club would gamble on him. Agree with this but think that he will get a job and fairly quickly, if only to get money in.
|
|
eppinggas
Administrator
Ian Alexander
Don't care
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 8,604
|
Post by eppinggas on Oct 27, 2023 9:26:26 GMT
I am not a fan of Barton as a man, but as a football manager (only) he has my respect. He turned the club around on the football pitch, and we were starting to build a decent football team in League One (again). He is a decent manager who will have no trouble finding another club. I find this a strange time to let him go. He has a long contract and whilst we have not set League One on fire (yet), we are not even halfway through the season. Given that we always start slowly I still had expectations for this season. As many have said, a devisive character who regularly embarasses the club, so hopefully we can move forward as a unified fanbase again.Absolutely critical we get the right person in, there is still potentially a promotion to be had this season (or next). UTG I wouldn't bet on that Rich A lot of Facebook fans slagging off the 'Barton haters' and saying none of them go to matches anyway and not true fans, etc. etc A lot of the Barton supporters are very angry with everyone, from the owners to his critics.Don't expect too much unity just yet! Bit like Trump supporters. The more embarrassing Trump becomes, the more his supporters double down on him. And the longer the blind support goes on, the harder it is to admit you've been backing an idiot all along. I see the same behaviour with Barton sycophants. Are the staunchly pro-Barton lot a bigger number than the staunchly anti-Barton brigade? Thankfully it's now a moot point.Because. He has gone. Time to move on. For the first time in 975 days. UTG.
|
|
|
Post by laughinggas on Oct 27, 2023 9:41:44 GMT
Funny old game, Tisdale slated for not getting striker in, after chasing just one. With Barton was someone else's fault we did not get one in.
|
|