warehamgas
Predictions League
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 3,591
|
Post by warehamgas on Dec 23, 2021 15:20:27 GMT
Good post tenniscourt. Yes, you’re right in so many ways. Leach played several 4 day games last season and none the season before. I can understand people questioning his place but I’m just not sure what the alternative is given his record over a period of time is much better than those other choices. I remember those friendly matches England used to have in Australia to give them good preparation, obviously change happens but sometimes it’s not always for the better! Thank you for your good wishes in Australia. Unfortunately the trip was postponed yesterday. After a long awaited hospital appointment yesterday my wife has to have urgent surgery so it has been put back so we can’t go. We are all disappointed, wife, grandchildren and son and me. But unavoidable and family and health comes first. Never mind, we’re better off than many. Have a very happy Christmas and new year! Hope your wife recovers quickly from her surgery. Thank you Nobby. When a consultant says no to the trip and you need to have it done now you tend to listen. Should all be ok in the end though. Thanks. 👍
|
|
|
Post by lostinspace on Dec 26, 2021 8:27:31 GMT
just woeful....end of
|
|
|
Post by alftupper on Dec 26, 2021 15:08:27 GMT
Catching practice for the Australians. Especially behind the stumps. Tentative prods or airy wafts, match after match. We look like the opposition normally do, facing Anderson and Broad under a cloudy sky, at Trent Bridge.
There`s fighting talk from Root at the end of each day`s play, but I think that they`ve already given this up as a bad job. Unless the Aussies relax after going 3-0 up, or rain intervenes, another whitewash looks inevitable.
|
|
bluetornados
Predictions League
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 15,768
|
Post by bluetornados on Dec 26, 2021 21:02:32 GMT
Australia will score at 3 an over which is 270, minus the 124 they are behind leaves them probably at 150+ at the end of day 2.
It is totally woeful, hard to watch and take, a Christmas miracle is needed to pull off 3 draws, but 5-0 looks likely.
|
|
bluetornados
Predictions League
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 15,768
|
Post by bluetornados on Dec 27, 2021 0:45:32 GMT
Latest: 00.45am
Australia 87-3 - Anderson, Robinson & Wood (98 behind)
|
|
|
Post by Nobbygas on Dec 27, 2021 7:57:14 GMT
......and just when you think it can't get any worse.......
|
|
|
Post by alftupper on Dec 27, 2021 8:14:56 GMT
......and just when you think it can't get any worse....... Woke up just after 7. England 22-2. Watched five minutes highlights of the Australian wickets going down, then went back to live score. England 22-4. It`s like the early 80s, when Marshall, Garner, Holding etc, would take a wrecking ball to our batting.
|
|
|
The Ashes
Dec 27, 2021 10:45:51 GMT
via mobile
Post by lostinspace on Dec 27, 2021 10:45:51 GMT
......and just when you think it can't get any worse....... Woke up just after 7. England 22-2. Watched five minutes highlights of the Australian wickets going down, then went back to live score. England 22-4. It`s like the early 80s, when Marshall, Garner, Holding etc, would take a wrecking ball to our batting.
I was thinking this just before this test started, and my thinking was that this would have been worse now that what it was in those heady WI days..
|
|
|
Post by Nobbygas on Dec 27, 2021 10:48:04 GMT
Who, in their right minds, would think an opening pair of Hameed and Crawley would be a good idea. The coaching staff have to go, the selectors have to go, and Root has to be replaced as Captain.
|
|
|
The Ashes
Dec 27, 2021 11:04:04 GMT
via mobile
Post by lostinspace on Dec 27, 2021 11:04:04 GMT
Who, in their right minds, would think an opening pair of Hameed and Crawley would be a good idea. The coaching staff have to go, the selectors have to go, and Root has to be replaced as Captain. As Wareham indicated in an earlier post,there will be several test careers finished after this tour, two bowlers for sure despite one taking 4 in the Aussie innings and possibly two batsman, though some should be if their own volition , otherwise should be asked to step down along with those responsible for this abysmal display and preparation , COVID is no excuse for this, Cricket Australia have done as good a job as is possible to protect both camps and should be applauded for it
|
|
|
Post by alftupper on Dec 27, 2021 12:57:14 GMT
Who, in their right minds, would think an opening pair of Hameed and Crawley would be a good idea. The coaching staff have to go, the selectors have to go, and Root has to be replaced as Captain. Don`t disagree, but who are going to replace these people? Who are going to open, if not the batsmen we have in Australia? Who will take over the captaincy from Root? I was never in favour of him being captain, in the first place.
I`d have given the job to Anderson or Broad, and let Root concentrate on doing what he does so wonderfully well. So who next? Stokes? Are we going to make him bat, bowl and lead the team?
Maybe he`d thrive on the extra pressure, or maybe we`ll be depriving ourselves of arguably the best all rounder in cricket.
|
|
|
Post by tenniscourtgas on Dec 27, 2021 14:37:34 GMT
Agree with this post. Even if Root is replaced as captain, who is 100% guaranteed out of the present side, to be a certain starter for several tests in a row, especially with Anderson/ Broad being rotated, rested, to be the new choice? I can only think of Root himself, and Stokes, and as has been pointed out, it would be putting too much of a workload on him, as happened with Botham all those years ago. New Zealand are due for a test series in June, and with their battery of quality seam bowlers, we can expect more probable batting pain, but Woakes will be back in conditions that suit him, which should make the series more balanced. First Ashes series I can remember was 1958-58, when we lost 4-0, which was a big shock to me as a 9 year old! I can recall we were all out for 87 in one match, and in one of the innings we were 7-3. The batting was always collapsing, despite May and Cowdrey, with some contributions from Tom Graveney, and Trueman and Statham were at their peak. It was the end of the road for players such as Jim Laker, Tony Lock, Godfrey Evans and Trevor Bailey, famous Ashes heroes in the post war years, Graveney was left out for two or three seasons. The team was completely re built the following summer, May and Cowdrey were still there, but younger players such as Dexter, Pullar, Subba Row and Barrington added to the batting, making an immediate impact for years. Can’t really see the same sort of thing happening next summer, unfortunately,
|
|
warehamgas
Predictions League
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 3,591
|
Post by warehamgas on Dec 27, 2021 15:06:49 GMT
Who, in their right minds, would think an opening pair of Hameed and Crawley would be a good idea. The coaching staff have to go, the selectors have to go, and Root has to be replaced as Captain. Don`t disagree, but who are going to replace these people? Who are going to open, if not the batsmen we have in Australia? Who will take over the captaincy from Root? I was never in favour of him being captain, in the first place.
I`d have given the job to Anderson or Broad, and let Root concentrate on doing what he does so wonderfully well. So who next? Stokes? Are we going to make him bat, bowl and lead the team?
Maybe he`d thrive on the extra pressure, or maybe we`ll be depriving ourselves of arguably the best all rounder in cricket.
There’s the dilemma in a nutshell. This lot have been poor but they are probably the best we have. We can make the odd change here and there but as a group of players I’m hard pressed to come up with any answers as to who else should be chosen. Who to have as a captain, no idea. Stokes may have been the best player but he’s not done anything since coming back into the team but he may thrive on the pressure. Trouble is the preparation was crap, the coaching seems not to be the best and stories about players disagreeing with selection and tactics are coming out. Some strong leadership needed I think and whilst being a top batsman Joe Root is mediocre as a captain. Ironic in the week Raymond Illingworth died. A player who was in the team almost for his captaincy alone. No one messed with him, remember him taking on the hill and the crowd in Sydney in 1971, and winning.
|
|
|
Post by Nobbygas on Dec 27, 2021 15:44:46 GMT
I don't know enough about the personalities in the England camp to suggest a future Captain. Nor do I know enough about the various captain's on the County Circuit. Apparently Buttler would have been a good pick (or so I hear) but there has to be doubts about his ability to play Test cricket. As a wicketkeeper/batsman he is lacking in both aspects at Test level. Would Foakes do a better job? Only one way to find out. Maybe play Buttler as just a batsman? Stokes as Captain? No. Why isn't Rashid playing Test cricket? Surely he would be a much more dangerous spinner than Leach? Give Jason Roy another go at opening? He only ever played five tests after all ! It can't be any worse than what we have now. Time to look at players like Livingston and Bracey? I think both would bring a bit of mental toughness to the team. Mahood is another?
I remember when Trescothick was picked for England. At the time he didn't have that good a record in County cricket, but he was selected by ? (can't remember his name) as he felt Marcus had the batting talent to succeed at Test level. He finished with a Test average of 43 ! Are there players out that like that? Are they being spotted? It appears that scoring a lot of runs at County level doesn't mean you're a good player. We are seeing proof of that in every test match we play. Shall we search South Africa for some young players ala Alan Lamb or Kevin Peterson? We really are in desperate straights. The ECB need to take a long hard look at themselves. Does English cricket need the 100 as well as a T20 tournament? Why are we playing the 100 when no other country in the world does? Are the ECB too arrogant and are they expecting the rest of the world to follow their lead? With both T20 and the 100 there isn't enough time in the English summer for many four day games, which really is the breeding ground for Test prospects. India, Australia and New Zealand all play T20, One Day and Test cricket to a high standard. All have strong National leagues.
The end of day two in a Test match. England have lost fourteen wickets and are still 51 runs behind. Just let that sink in.
Michael Vaughan got it spot on yesterday when he said the only thing England have got right on this tour was to turn up on time.
Yes, both Illingworth and Brearley were there for their Captaincy and not necessarily for their personal cricketing contributions. The same currently could be said of Morgan in the T20 team.
|
|
warehamgas
Predictions League
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 3,591
|
Post by warehamgas on Dec 27, 2021 15:48:19 GMT
I don't know enough about the personalities in the England camp to suggest a future Captain. Nor do I know enough about the various captain's on the County Circuit. Apparently Buttler would have been a good pick (or so I hear) but there has to be doubts about his ability to play Test cricket. As a wicketkeeper/batsman he is lacking in both aspects at Test level. Would Foakes do a better job? Only one way to find out. Maybe play Buttler as just a batsman? Stokes as Captain? No. Why isn't Rashid playing Test cricket? Surely he would be a much more dangerous spinner than Leach? Give Jason Roy another go at opening? He only ever played five tests after all ! It can't be any worse than what we have now. Time to look at players like Livingston and Bracey? I think both would bring a bit of mental toughness to the team. Mahood is another? I remember when Trescothick was picked for England. At the time he didn't have that good a record in County cricket, but he was selected by ? (can't remember his name) as he felt Marcus had the batting talent to succeed at Test level. He finished with a Test average of 43 ! Are there players out that like that? Are they being spotted? It appears that scoring a lot of runs at County level doesn't mean you're a good player. We are seeing proof of that in every test match we play. Shall we search South Africa for some young players ala Alan Lamb or Kevin Peterson? We really are in desperate straights. The ECB need to take a long hard look at themselves. Does English cricket need the 100 as well as a T20 tournament? Why are we playing the 100 when no other country in the world does? Are the ECB too arrogant and are they expecting the rest of the world to follow their lead? With both T20 and the 100 there isn't enough time in the English summer for many four day games, which really is the breeding ground for Test prospects. India, Australia and New Zealand all play T20, One Day and Test cricket to a high standard. All have strong National leagues. The end of day two in a Test match. England have lost fourteen wickets and are still 51 runs behind. Just let that sink in. Michael Vaughan got it spot on yesterday when he said the only thing England have got right on this tour was to turn up on time. Yes, both Illingworth and Brearley were there for their Captaincy and not necessarily for their personal cricketing contributions. The same currently could be said of Morgan in the T20 team. Duncan Fletcher as coach and Nasser H or perhaps Michael V as captain I think Nobby. Whoever was captain it was Fletcher who wanted Tres.
|
|
|
Post by Nobbygas on Dec 27, 2021 15:55:32 GMT
I don't know enough about the personalities in the England camp to suggest a future Captain. Nor do I know enough about the various captain's on the County Circuit. Apparently Buttler would have been a good pick (or so I hear) but there has to be doubts about his ability to play Test cricket. As a wicketkeeper/batsman he is lacking in both aspects at Test level. Would Foakes do a better job? Only one way to find out. Maybe play Buttler as just a batsman? Stokes as Captain? No. Why isn't Rashid playing Test cricket? Surely he would be a much more dangerous spinner than Leach? Give Jason Roy another go at opening? He only ever played five tests after all ! It can't be any worse than what we have now. Time to look at players like Livingston and Bracey? I think both would bring a bit of mental toughness to the team. Mahood is another? I remember when Trescothick was picked for England. At the time he didn't have that good a record in County cricket, but he was selected by ? (can't remember his name) as he felt Marcus had the batting talent to succeed at Test level. He finished with a Test average of 43 ! Are there players out that like that? Are they being spotted? It appears that scoring a lot of runs at County level doesn't mean you're a good player. We are seeing proof of that in every test match we play. Shall we search South Africa for some young players ala Alan Lamb or Kevin Peterson? We really are in desperate straights. The ECB need to take a long hard look at themselves. Does English cricket need the 100 as well as a T20 tournament? Why are we playing the 100 when no other country in the world does? Are the ECB too arrogant and are they expecting the rest of the world to follow their lead? With both T20 and the 100 there isn't enough time in the English summer for many four day games, which really is the breeding ground for Test prospects. India, Australia and New Zealand all play T20, One Day and Test cricket to a high standard. All have strong National leagues. The end of day two in a Test match. England have lost fourteen wickets and are still 51 runs behind. Just let that sink in. Michael Vaughan got it spot on yesterday when he said the only thing England have got right on this tour was to turn up on time. Yes, both Illingworth and Brearley were there for their Captaincy and not necessarily for their personal cricketing contributions. The same currently could be said of Morgan in the T20 team. Duncan Fletcher as coach and Nasser H or perhaps Michael V as captain I think Nobby. Whoever was captain it was Fletcher who wanted Tres. That's right, it was Duncan Fletcher. The name escaped me when I was frantically typing. The point is, Tresco was not a top run scorer in county cricket at the time, but Fletcher thought his technique would be suited for Test cricket, and he was right.
|
|
bluetornados
Predictions League
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 15,768
|
Post by bluetornados on Dec 27, 2021 20:37:37 GMT
Duncan Fletcher as coach and Nasser H or perhaps Michael V as captain I think Nobby. Whoever was captain it was Fletcher who wanted Tres. That's right, it was Duncan Fletcher. The name escaped me when I was frantically typing. The point is, Tresco was not a top run scorer in county cricket at the time, but Fletcher thought his technique would be suited for Test cricket, and he was right. Yes, to put it in a football form, Alf Ramsey did not pick the best players but the right players in each position to do the right job, the same as Trescothick for test cricket. Marcus Trescothick was born on Christmas day 1975 he went on to play 76 tests and had a 43.79 batting average, (oh to have him now)
|
|
|
Post by alftupper on Dec 27, 2021 23:43:51 GMT
I don't know enough about the personalities in the England camp to suggest a future Captain. Nor do I know enough about the various captain's on the County Circuit. Apparently Buttler would have been a good pick (or so I hear) but there has to be doubts about his ability to play Test cricket. As a wicketkeeper/batsman he is lacking in both aspects at Test level. Would Foakes do a better job? Only one way to find out. Maybe play Buttler as just a batsman? Stokes as Captain? No. Why isn't Rashid playing Test cricket? Surely he would be a much more dangerous spinner than Leach? Give Jason Roy another go at opening? He only ever played five tests after all ! It can't be any worse than what we have now. Time to look at players like Livingston and Bracey? I think both would bring a bit of mental toughness to the team. Mahood is another? I remember when Trescothick was picked for England. At the time he didn't have that good a record in County cricket, but he was selected by ? (can't remember his name) as he felt Marcus had the batting talent to succeed at Test level. He finished with a Test average of 43 ! Are there players out that like that? Are they being spotted? It appears that scoring a lot of runs at County level doesn't mean you're a good player. We are seeing proof of that in every test match we play. Shall we search South Africa for some young players ala Alan Lamb or Kevin Peterson? We really are in desperate straights. The ECB need to take a long hard look at themselves. Does English cricket need the 100 as well as a T20 tournament? Why are we playing the 100 when no other country in the world does? Are the ECB too arrogant and are they expecting the rest of the world to follow their lead? With both T20 and the 100 there isn't enough time in the English summer for many four day games, which really is the breeding ground for Test prospects. India, Australia and New Zealand all play T20, One Day and Test cricket to a high standard. All have strong National leagues. The end of day two in a Test match. England have lost fourteen wickets and are still 51 runs behind. Just let that sink in. Michael Vaughan got it spot on yesterday when he said the only thing England have got right on this tour was to turn up on time. Yes, both Illingworth and Brearley were there for their Captaincy and not necessarily for their personal cricketing contributions. The same currently could be said of Morgan in the T20 team. Both Rashid as a bowler and Roy as a batsman, have far better averages in the one day game than in the Test arena. Rashid has taken 60 Test wickets at nearly 40 apiece, and Roy averages 18 with the bat. Also Rashid has already stated that he didn`t want to play red ball cricket, and had to be persuaded to return. In his last test match in the WI, he took 0-118. Don`t think his heart is really in it. Having said all that, I`d still rather have him there than Leach. At least Rashid can put bat to ball with some purpose.
Sadly, ( as a Glos fan ) Bracey looked totally out of his depth, playing for England. However, if the powers that be decide to give him another chance next year, give him a proper go. Tell him he`s there for the whole summer, now show us what you can do. Same with Livingstone, if they decide he`s the answer to our prayers. No good picking them, when they know that a couple of failures and they`re out again. Agree absolutely with your comments re our domestic season. That T20 and 100 ( forms of the game for anyone with the attention span of the half life of a Hydrogen atom ) have more or less replaced the four day game, is heartbreaking to me. Of course there`s a place for it, just not so much, and not to the detriment of the longer format of the game. As Aristotle once said, "You`re going to reap just what you sow." Or was it Lou Reed?
|
|
bluetornados
Predictions League
Joined: June 2014
Posts: 15,768
|
Post by bluetornados on Dec 28, 2021 0:38:02 GMT
England 68 all out (00.51am) - Australia win by an innings and 14 runs.
Boland 4 overs, 1 maiden, 7 runs, 6 wickets.
Root top score with 28, Stokes 11.
Australia 3-0 up and retain the Ashes.
Not even 2 1/2 days play.
A total and utter inept disgrace.
|
|
|
Post by Nobbygas on Dec 28, 2021 7:33:19 GMT
Fer God's sake, say Covid has ripped through the squad and get them on the first plane/boat out of there. Collectively they've given up.
|
|