I didn't think I coud do the crap one without doing the good one - possibly things up that there's 3 posts on this thread and 3 pages worth on the other one..
GK - Anssi Jakkola (Early days but looks better than we've had for ages and it was mostly endless loans this decade anyway).
RB - Michael Smith (People don't seem to like him but he was class).
CB - Tom Lockyer (Should be considered a club legend).
CB - Jake Clarke-Salter (Wasn't here long but I thought he was good for us).
LB - Lee Brown (Not sure we've had a better one in the last 25 years).
RW - Billy Bodin (Not really sure who else we could have).
CM - Stuart Campbell (Still a legend).
CM - Chris Lines (For both stints).
LW - Andy Monkhouse (Under rated).
CF - Matt Taylor (2 promotions).
CF - Ellis Harrisson (Possibly the most important goal in our history).
Clarke-Salter??? I trust you missed the end of season game against Millwall where he was personally liable for 3 of the goals (that gave Millwall a play-off place). I thought something was amiss when he turned up in flip-flops and wearing shades. And yes, I know he went on to play in final of the WC U-20's, conceding a penalty in the process. He's gone on to the dizzying heights of... continuing to be chelski loanee.